A Spotted Problem

The connections, that advancements in technology and transportation have made, make the 21st century world infinitely faster in almost every way, something AP Human Geography has drilled into my mind. While this has improved the world we live in, our connected world has created numerous, almost insurmountable, problems. I have always been fascinated with why the world is the way it is and I often find myself delving into the natural world, mostly the local woods, parks, and streams. Because of this, when a new face showed up in my backyard, both figuratively and literally, I became a little concerned. This new pest was the Spotted Lanternfly, a species of insect that poses a major danger to Pennsylvania.

Opening a Can of Worms

The Spotted Lanternfly, Lycorma delicatula, was first sighted in Berks County, Pennsylvania in 2014(“Spotted Lanternfly Program Information”). From there it has continued to spread rapidly in the southeastern part of the state, reaching Montgomery County in 2018. The planthopper spreads so rapidly because of its ability to lay eggs on almost any flat surface (“Spotted Lanternfly Program Information”). Combine this with speed of the modern world and you will find a recipe for disaster.  As the Spotted Lanternflies found themselves at home in the Pennsylvania ecosystem, they quickly became an invasive species. An invasive species is a species of plant or animal that has taken root in a non-native location and may cause economic, environmental, or humans harm (Hill). The Spotted Lanternfly has the potential to do all three in Pennsylvania.

My Story

I first took notice of the little planthopper in the summer of 2018. Of course I’d heard mention of the insect from neighbors and my retired park ranger grandfather, but it wasn’t tangible to me in my small suburban world. It’s hard to fully appreciate anything until you see it starring you in the face, like the Lanternfly, a problem hidden in plain sight. My first encounter with the insect was a brief skirmish with a young nymph as it jumped on the spade I was using to remove a particularly frustrating weed, I stopped and starred.

It turns out what I saw was a nymph in the third instar of development. Instars are developmental stages between birth and molting. The Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture has identified four unique instars of the Spotted Lanternfly (“Spotted Lanternfly”). The first three instars look almost identical, all of them with black bodies and white spots. In the fourth instar the insect develops the red color and larger body of the adult fly. As the insect matures it increases in size, with the fourth instar being almost the same size as the adult. Finally, after molting, the fly develops the characteristic set of brown and red wings, with black spotting.

Once I had confirmed that the mystery insect was indeed a Lanternfly, I returned to the yard and swiftly ended its life along with a few others I found. After this I only saw a few more of the creatures, but in the back of my mind I knew that they were out there. Simply biding their time, waiting to molt and transform into a menace. As the first month of summer concluded, the fly had all but slipped from my mind.

To put it bluntly, this was a big mistake. Soon swarms of Spotted Lanternflies crowded shopping centers, trees, and the football field. The insect had begun an all out war on the local ecosystem. The biggest danger of an invasive species is a loss of habitat (Hill). While the Spotted Lanternfly has not yet caused severe damage to our native ecosystem, it has the potential to inflict major economic wounds. Pennsylvania, having a strong agricultural industry, is a timebomb when a plant sucking invasive species is thrown into the mix. The Spotted Lanternfly poses a danger to 25 plant species in PA, a combination of viticultural products, fruits, and hardwood trees; an industry that all together is worth over $17.134 billion dollars (“Spotted Lanternfly Program Information”). Damaging these industries will put a damper on economic growth in Pennsylvania. This teetering threat, so close to my own heart,  became an itch that I felt needed to be scratched by more than just the Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture and the Penn State Cooperative Extension.

What could I do? Traps?

How could I make a difference? With these questions I set off. My first instinct was to kill as many of the insects as possible. The Philadelphia Premium outlets, off of 422, had droves both flying and hopping, making a mess. After an hour of casually walking around swatting Lanternflies, my corpse count reached 154. However, I knew that only swatting the adults wouldn’t solve the problem. There were simply too many of them to kill in one blow. (When I started this project I began by brainstorming ideas). First it was all about the trap. How could I catch and kill as many nuisance insects as possible. I sketched out a few designs, but most ended up looking like other fly catchers that already existed.

Egg Scraping

As I attempted to universalize fly traps, I continued to research. I soon realized that simply killing the Spotted Lanternflies wouldn’t be enough. Maybe I could destroy their eggs. When I communicated with the Master Gardeners at the Montgomery County Penn State extension office they recommended egg scraping. In basic terms: slash and burn, destroying the eggs before they could hatch, preventing a mess. However, as with killing adults you can’t get them all, allowing the continuation of the cycle. What I really needed was another method, a way to kill the bugs after they hatched, but before they could lay more eggs.  The Master Gardeners, suggested wrapping trees with sticky tape or tree banding. The issue then became what trees to band. In brief, as many trees as possible, but there are some prime targets.

Tree Banding

The Tree of Heaven is the tree most commonly associated with the Spotted Lanternfly. The tree, native to central China and Taiwan and introduced to Pennsylvania in 1784, is an invasive species the same as the pest that feeds off it(Fryer). These trees, once properly prepared, become trap trees fit to demolish hundreds of flies. While trap trees work, Spotted Lanternflies will still feed on other trees, allowing Sooty Mold to grow, killing the trees (“Spotted Lanternfly”). This make mass tree banding a necessary action against the Spotted Lanternfly. This method has the capability to inflict massive casualties and would be effective in open areas with many trees, for example the Perkiomen Valley High School campus. With this information I am moving toward running banding tests, to measure the effectiveness and hazards, on campus.

Fungi

In the final days of this project I was gifted insight into another potential cure for the plague of the Spotted Lanternfly. A biological pathogen, something that I had mused about when beginning this project. I had imagined creating a vector virus that could wipe out the Spotted Lanternfly quickly and easily, but never really imagined this possible. Be that as it may this pathogen comes in the form of two fungi. The fungi Batkoa major and Beauveria bassiana have been found by researchers at Cornell University to kill Spotted Lanternflies  (Lewis). This is an exciting new step towards the eradication of the insect.

In the end my efforts this year have fallen short. The actions that I have succeeded in taking have come to late in the school year for completion by its end. However, I plan to continue to work at this problem as the years go on, hopefully until the Spotted Lanternfly has run its course and gone from our ecosystem.

Further Reading

Fryer, Janet L. “Ailanthus Altissima.” Ailanthus Altissima, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Rocky Mountain Research Station, Fire Sciences Laboratory, 2010, www.fs.fed.us/database/feis/plants/tree/ailalt/all.html.

Hill, Jacob. “Invasive Species: How They Affect the Environment.” EnvironmentalScience.org, 23 Feb. 2015, www.environmentalscience.org/invasive-species.

Lewis, Jim. “Researchers Find 2 Fungi Killed Spotted Lanternflies in Berks.” Reading Eagle, Reading Eagle, 1 May 2019, www.readingeagle.com/news/article/researchers-find-2-fungi-killed-spotted-lanternflies-in-berks?fbclid=IwAR1tX7k1rXgSHupAPzFCRvE3ly7wnyygJVF3bki3YA4gPvS37dKJNCvj_B0.

“Pennsylvania Wine Fact Sheet.” Pennsylvaniawine.com, The Pennsylvania Wine Association, pennsylvaniawine.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/PressSheet2016_FNL.pdf.

Reading Eagle. “What You Need to Know about the Spotted Lanternfly Invasion.” Reading Eagle, Reading Eagle, 9 Oct. 2018, www.readingeagle.com/news/article/everything-you-need-to-know-about-spotted-lanternfly.

Redding, Russell C. “NOTICES.” PA Bulletin, Doc. No. 18-968>, 5 May 2018, 9:00 AM, www.pabulletin.com/secure/data/vol48/48-21/825.html.

“Spotted Lanternfly.” Penn State Extension, Pennsylvania State University, 2018, extension.psu.edu/spotted-lanternfly.

“Spotted Lanternfly Program Information.” Quarantine, Pennsylvania Department of Agriculture, 2019, www.agriculture.pa.gov/Plants_Land_Water/PlantIndustry/Entomology/spotted_lanternfly/program-information/Pages/default.aspx.

P.P. Update 8. The Endgame.

Today is the last Day.

Funny joke right.

In honesty I would not be very comfortable if today were the last day of the project. From the beginning I knew that this task would be a daunting one and it has proven to be so. While I don’t feel comfortable closing out my project at this instant, I am of course not without anything.

Since February I been researching and revising my ideas in an attempt to rationalize the issue of the Spotted Lantern Fly. My research needs to be put in to a tangible/physical form. This may come via my paper, but I may want to do something else like an informational video perhaps. My initial objective was to find a solution or make a difference in the fight against the spotted lantern fly. To do this I was going to create a physical product to kill or prevent their spread. At this point I have all but scrapped this idea, it may be something I pursue in the future, however not soon. Also a solution may have been found in the form of a fungus. You can find information here.

Beauveria bassiana

At this point I need to do two things.

  • Research: Paper and another tangible form.
    • PSA/Informational Video
  • Organize a “hunt”

Both of these are manageable with the time that I have left and I look forward to the completion of a step in this big issue.

P.P. W. 7/8 Straight Out Update.

I’m tired, lost, and a little bit confused. Progress if any has been slow and I have been lacking motivation to make it. I haven’t produced anything that I really consider to be tangible since my elevator pitch. I have jumped from point to point which and have found it rather difficult to root an angle I want to pursue with the Spotted Lanternfly.

I think my best course of action now it to abandon all of my previous endeavors and  work on a completely different angle. I want continue to work with the issue of the Spotted Lanternfly. My initial idea was to produce a project or come up with an idea that would help to contain or eradicate the insect. However, I don’t really know if this is feasible for my position and it might be more suitable to just design or model such a product rather than actually produce it.

My focus now will be a redesign of my mission and to produce something tangible for the research I have done.

As of now I don’t think that I am on the best track for completion of some kind in two months. I hope by adjusting my mission I can make this a much more reasonable timeline. From here I also want to generate some social media presence, since I want part of my focus to be in raising awareness of the issue at hand.

I also want to have a conference with Mr. Heidt to hopefully gain some wisdom that can aid my new objective.

P.P. W5. Really Digging In

February 8th, 2019

To begin,

I did not accomplish my goal from last week:

Reaching out to PSU and the PDA.

However, I did make some headway. I have been able to process my thinking and group my project into chunks that I want to work on. They are a little hard to word out, but are part of my Preliminary Proposal. This next week I hope to continue to flesh about these chunk and begin my research to aid me. I want to put contacting experts on to the back burner for at least a week, so I can better my understanding of the issue and have more relevant ideas.

Three of my most important research/project goal questions are:

What is being done and Who is doing it? And why is it working/Not working?

What is the Spotted Lanternfly/What is it doing in PA?

Finally, the end all be all:

What can I do? How can I make an impact? What can I build or design to help my community.

This last question is very broad, because it need to answer the first two first. These driving questions will help me focus my efforts on the main issues. They also provide direction and guidance to keep my on course.

I would really like to apply Design Thinking, I don’t know much about it, but this link

https://think360studio.com/what-is-design-thinking-and-design-thinking-process/

seems to give a pretty good run down.

 

Cheers,

Yours Truly,

See you next week.

P.P W 3/4.

February 1, 2018

This week was full of minor set backs. First the snow and then some sickness. Overall I was able to accomplish more than I had expected to .

I have settled on the Spotted Lantern Fly angle for my project. Maybe not permanently but it’s a start. I would like to keep a mindfulness project on the back burner or even pursue it outside of school.

In the realm of research I have built a good base on which to expand from in order to get my four annotated sources for the end of this week. I started with the question: “What is the Spotted Lantern Fly and Why is it a problem?” It turns out that the Spotted Lantern Fly is a type of insect called a “tree hopper” which is very common. It is invasive to PA and NJ. This is the definition on a very basic level. The answer to why its a problem is a little more complicated. Essentially it attacks different types of trees and other fruit producing plants and causes them to die.  In PA and NJ this could cause a problem to the agricultural economy.

This general searching lead to the next question: “What is being done and by whom?” Turns out that research is being spear headed by Penn State University and the PDA.

My goal for this week is to 1. continue research and build farther with my annotated sources. 2. Reach out to both PSU and the PDA. I also would like to contact more local sources like the Perkiomen Watershed Conservancy and the 4H Center in Skippack.

Image result for typewriter

 

P.P W2. Continuing the Pursuit.

January 18th, 2019

To begin this week was the not the most productive in terms of my Purpose Project. I did achieve something, which, in my book is always better than nothing.

I accomplished two thing this week. I continued to brainstorm ideas for potential projects and I continued to develop one of my previous ideas. First my brain storm. My favorite idea that I came up with was learning Meditation and Mindfulness. In A.P. Human we are beginning our unit on religion. As part of our study we learn about Buddhism, in which meditation is a key part. That got me thinking. I’ve heard meditation has many positive benefits. I think that if I could learn and practice meditation I could greatly improve my mind. I would like to flesh this idea out in full over the next week.

Second I looked into my Spotted Lantern Fly idea. To do this I listened to a podcast by Jim the Arborist, who is located in Bucks County PA. I found out some new things and learned a bit too. My biggest take away from this was how I was actually going to do anything in the Winter. I would really like to go into the “field” literally and figuratively to do research in our area. In the winter this would be very difficult. This is something that I need to work out over the next week.

I really appreciated the feedback from Mr. Heidt, as well as a few other classmates who happened to read my post in the aggregator. Mr. Heidt found that the idea fit well with the directive of the project and noted that there are a number of resources in our immediate area. I also agree with him in that perhaps I could broaden my lens a bit to encompass more than just the Lantern Fly. The feed back I received from my peers was positive as well and I attribute this to the fact  that we have all had quite an awakening experience with the bug.

My goals for this coming week are as follows:

  1. Continue working into the Spotted Lantern Fly and like angles.
  2. Look into a meditation and mindfulness project.

Podcast: https://itunes.apple.com/us/podcast/clouds-dirt-tree-care/id1389789553?mt=2

man_meditating_-1-678x381

 

P.P. W1. What the heck am I going to do?

January, 10th 2018

What the heck am I going to do? What am I supposed to do? Simply put, WHAT?!

Recently my GHEnglish class was introduced to the Purpose/Passion/20Time project. This project is an opportunity for me to pick something that I’m passionate about and learn or do something with our topic of choice. There are three stipulations:

First: The project must be completed with a topic you are passionate about.

Second: You cannot already be doing this exact thing.

Third: The project my benefit others in some way.

To begin I’ve had a vague notion of what this project was about since 8th grade, all of that was associated with Mr. Heidt. Granted all of this knowledge was gathered from bits and pieces of whispers about the high school, but I got picture. It was a very different, but very powerful project.

As I had it officially introduced to me I understand the power and weight of an undertaking such as this. My first thought was to be mad and worried that I had to a huge project, but once I realized the purpose of the project these emotions subsided. Listening to the seniors talk gave me a good deal of confidence, knowing that it would be hard, but accomplishable. I was a little intrigued that they were surprised they lost a little interested when the project didn’t go there way. That is something I had anticipated since the beginning.

Now to get to some of my ideas. The first idea that really took hold was designing an electric Jeep to prove to my dad that I could find a Jeep with good gas mileage. I thought this could be a great opportunity to learn about automotives, engineering, and electronics. However, my hopes were soon dashed when I learned jeep would be releasing an electric Jeep Wrangler in 2021. While I still would lie to look into this, I don’t think it would be in the spirit of the project. After this I was approached by A.F. with an idea to document the projects of the others in our class. This could be used as a teaching tool for future students.

Finally I have come to my most recent idea of researching and documenting the natural resources of the Perkiomen Valley Area. This train of though lead me to my hatred of the Spotted Lantern Fly.  I think that it would be a great project to research current methods and design my own way to control the spread of this invasive species.

spotted lanternfly adult lateral view (greghoover)

 

Website Powered by WordPress.com.

Up ↑

Design a site like this with WordPress.com
Get started